The best golf simulator impact screen should have features like minimal ball bounce back, effective noise reduction, excellent durability, a size that fits your space, and, of course, within your budget.
I acquired the SIGPROTM Premium Golf Simulator Impact Screen earlier this year. After five months of consistent use, I can confidently affirm that it is the top choice among golf simulator impact screens. Its remarkable durability and straightforward installation process have impressed me. What pleasantly surprised me the most was its minimal noise during use; the sound of the ball hitting the screen is notably quieter than the impact on the ball itself.
The low bounceback feature and high-quality materials further contribute to its excellence. Compatible with my projector, it delivers clear and crisp images. While it may have been a bit pricey, I find it worth every penny. Before settling on this screen, I experimented with several others and ranked them based on their standout performances during my testing phase.
- SIGPROTM Premium Golf Simulator Impact Screen
- SIGTM Preferred Finished Golf Impact Screen
- HomeCourse Pro Retractable Golf Simulator Screen
| Image | Product | Detail | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
| Buy Now For $381.79 | |
 | SIGTM Preferred Finished Golf Impact Screen |
| Buy Now For $295.99 |
 | HomeCourse Pro Retractable Golf Simulator Screen |
| Buy Now For $1,999 |
In the rest of this article, I will delve into a comprehensive review of the distinctive features that set these impact screens apart as the best in the market. I’ll share insights into their performance during testing, discuss the advantages they offer, and highlight any drawbacks associated with each. Let’s begin!
Specification Comparison
These impact screens feature high-quality materials, ensuring both durability and performance. Here’s a brief overview, presenting their key specifications for a quick comparison.
| Golf Simulator Impact Screen | SIGPROTM Premium Golf Simulator Impact Screen | SIGTM Preferred Finished Golf Impact Screen | HomeCourse Pro Retractable Golf Simulator Screen |
| Fabric | Impact-resistant polyester | Impact-resistant polyester | ballistic-grade material |
| Price | $381.79 | $295.99 | $1,999 |
| Edge-to-edge measurement | 7’7” x 7’7” | 7’7” x 7’7” | 16″ |
SIGPROTM Premium Golf Simulator Impact Screen
$381.79
- Clear and crisp image.
- Minimal bleed-through.
- It has superior material quality and is highly durable.
- Super easy to install.
This is one of the best impact screens currently available. It can endure ball speeds reaching 250 mph. Its remarkable durability results from being crafted from high-quality materials that effectively absorb the impact of golf balls. Another notable feature is its ability to reduce the noise from ball contact significantly. Exclusive to the indoor golf shop, it offers a range of sizes, extending up to 10′ x 10′. While it may not be the most economical option, its exceptional performance ensures you get significant value for your investment.
Features
Constructed from thick and smooth fabric, this impact screen features two heavy-duty, tightly woven surfaces of impact-resistant polyester. These surfaces encapsulate vertical spacer yarns, forming a unique three-layered structure. This design effectively absorbs much of the impact, resulting in minimal ball bounceback.
The material also ensures a clear and realistic ball flight, guaranteeing the projected image is sharp and bright. The vertical spacers act as a “cushion,” dampening the noise emitted when your golf ball impacts the screen.
This impact screen is equipped with double-stitched black vinyl edges and grommets. It comes in various sizes, is suitable for rooms of different dimensions, and can be customized to meet your requirements.
Performance
Setting up the screen was a breeze, thanks to the provided fittings, making the installation process straightforward. I hooked up a 4K projector, and the picture quality was remarkably impressive. After weeks of use, the screen stayed in perfect condition and hit numerous balls.
The screen produces a clear image with minimal bounceback. Its exceptional quality suggests long-lasting durability, which is a significant improvement over my previous screen that wedges damaged.
Despite a few wrinkles from shipping, they smoothed out over time. The screen has endured numerous iron shots, and any minor imperfections didn’t affect gameplay on E6 golf courses.
Notably, the screen is remarkably quiet, with the sound of hitting the ball louder than the impact on the net. Adjusting the ball bungees allowed me to control the screen’s response, giving approximately 4-5 inches of give.
The design incorporates smooth spacer mesh fabric, reducing bleed-through and ensuring a grain-free effect for 4K image quality. However, I did observe scuff marks on the screen after a few months of use.
Although it’s a bit pricier than some simulator screens, it seems to be a “you get what you pay for” item. The impact is absorbed and muffled, causing balls to drop straight down instead of bouncing back.
I started using it twice a week with some friends; it has proven suitable for various players. I highly recommend this screen for anyone seeking to upgrade their simulator setup. Despite being slightly more expensive, its value makes it a worthwhile investment for any simulator setup.
What I liked
- Clear and crisp image.
- Minimal bleed-through.
- It has superior material quality and is highly durable.
- Low bounce back absorbs much of the impact and keeps the ball from bouncing around and potentially injuring you.
- Super easy to install.
What I didn’t like
- A bit expensive.
- Wrinkles from shipping stay on the screen.
SIGTM Preferred Finished Golf Impact Screen
SIGTM Preferred Finished Golf Impact Screen
$295.99
- Crafted from tightly woven, impact-resistant polyester for enhanced durability,.
- Finished edges and inclusive mounting hardware contribute to a hassle-free installation process.
- Provides noise reduction features, enhancing the overall simulator experience.
- It comes in a variety of sizes.
This more budget-friendly alternative delivers high quality, good image clarity, and noise reduction features. You can easily find one in various sizes that suits your simulator setup. What makes it particularly attractive is its affordability, being approximately 40% cheaper than the SIGTM Premium, yet it doesn’t compromise on performance. Although the image quality may not match the premium option, it is still impressive within its price range, making it a fantastic choice for your home simulator setup.
Features
This impact screen features a fabric crafted from tightly woven, impact-resistant polyester, fortified for enhanced durability. Completed with double-stitched black vinyl edges and grommets, the screen includes essential accessories such as ball bungees, zip ties, and shock cords for easy installation.
It is a single-layer, middle-tier golf impact screen available through the indoor golf shop.
Performance
Having hit around 300 irons into the screen, it has held up well. The included ball bungees work efficiently; a single bundle proved more than enough.
The screen performed exactly as expected, and I highly recommend using the suggested ball bungees for an easy installation. It has finished edges and inclusive mounting hardware, making the installation process much more convenient than raw screen material.
I recommend this screen if you don’t plan on using it as a movie theater screen. Due to its slightly rough weave surface, the image may be less crisp. However, it does offer decent noise reduction, making it suitable as an impact screen for a simulator. Consider the premium impact screen if you intend to use it for dual purposes, especially as a movie theater screen. But it’s an excellent choice for a dedicated impact screen in a simulator setup—especially if affordability and functionality are your main priorities.
What I liked
- Crafted from tightly woven, impact-resistant polyester for enhanced durability,.
- Finished edges and inclusive mounting hardware contribute to a hassle-free installation process.
- Provides noise reduction features, enhancing the overall simulator experience.
- It comes in a variety of sizes.
- It’s a lot more affordable than other alternatives.
What I didn’t like
- Image quality is not as great as the premium.
.
HomeCourse Pro Retractable Golf Simulator Screen
HomeCourse Pro Retractable Golf Simulator Screen
$1,999
- Operating wirelessly with a remote makes it user-friendly.
- Constructed with ballistic-grade material for long-lasting use.
- Pro-arms offer options for standard or extended configurations.
- The retractable feature efficiently reclaims your space when not in use.
This high-end impact screen features a premium retractable design that operates wirelessly and can be conveniently controlled via a remote. Known for its exceptional durability and ability to deliver an immersive experience, it does come with a premium price, surpassing $1,000, making it one of the pricier options on the market. It comes with a retractable golf screen.
- Ceiling mount kit
- Charging cable
- Remote control
- Easy-to-reach pole
Features
This impact screen incorporates a unique feature where the side netting can be extended, creating an expansive 14-foot projectable screen. Constructed from ballistic-grade material specifically engineered to absorb the impact of golf balls struck at point-blank range, this attribute contributes to the screen’s high quality and durability.
The ballistic-grade material forms an enclosure that contains errant shots in conjunction with pro-arms. A noteworthy addition is the pro arms’ flexibility, which allows them to be used in the standard configuration or opened to extend to an ultra-wide 14-foot projectable area, ideal for a 16:9 aspect ratio.
Furthermore, it operates wirelessly and includes a remote for convenient control. Its easy installation ensures a setup free from unnecessary wires that can become tangled and clutter the space. The retractable feature allows you to transform your space virtually into an indoor driving range or a golf simulator environment.
Performance
The HomeCourse ProScreen has a cool open design and is great for reclaiming space when not in use. However, the installation instructions don’t specify how to mount the screen regarding floor clearance, so I had to figure it out independently.
I did notice that if the screen touches the floor, it tends to distort during intense drives, messing with the projection. On the other hand, if it doesn’t touch the floor, the sides can cave in when fully extended.
After numerous 150-mph+ impacts, the central impact zone of the screen sags a bit, but overall, it’s holding up well. The “safety” screen around the net doesn’t stop a ball from going through, so I used several zip ties to reinforce it.
While the screen opens up more space, its retractable feature minimizes potential space issues. For its $2000 price, the ballistic screen has held up fine. It’s a pricey premium impact screen, and despite its performance and convenience, I wouldn’t recommend it unless you prioritize the retractable feature. There are more affordable options out there that still offer excellent performance and would serve you well.
What I liked:
- Operating wirelessly with a remote makes it user-friendly.
- Constructed with ballistic-grade material for long-lasting use.
- Pro-arms offer options for standard or extended configurations.
- The retractable feature efficiently reclaims your space when not in use.
What I didn’t like:
- With a price tag of over $1,000, it is expensive.
- After numerous high-speed impacts, the central area may sag slightly.
Factors you should consider when shopping for an impact screen for your simulator
Material Quality:
The material used in constructing the impact screen is a fundamental factor influencing its performance and longevity. Polyester and nylon are popular choices due to their durability and resistance to wear. Opting for high-quality materials ensures that your impact screen can withstand the repeated impact of golf balls.
Durability and Tightness of Weave:
Assessing the overall durability of the impact screen is crucial, especially if you plan to use your golf simulator frequently. Screens with reinforced edges and sturdy construction are essential to prevent fraying or damage over time. A durable screen ensures a longer lifespan and maintains consistent performance during every use.
The tightness of the weave or mesh of the impact screen is critical for image clarity and overall performance. A tighter weave generally contributes to a clearer image and better ball tracking. Screens with a high-quality weave offer an immersive experience, making it feel closer to playing on an actual golf course.
Resolution:
You should go for a high-resolution impact screen, vital for a visually engaging simulation. Higher-resolution screens, such as those with 1080p or 4K capabilities, provide sharp and detailed graphics. This enhances the overall realism of the virtual golfing experience, making it more enjoyable and true to life.
Size:
Consider the size of the impact screen based on the available space in your golf simulator setup. Striking a balance between a screen that is large enough for an immersive experience and one that fits comfortably within your designated area is crucial. Screens typically range from 7 feet to 14 feet in width, offering options for various setups.
Ease of Installation:
You should consider the installation process for the impact screen. Opt for screens with a convenient hanging system or frame. These are easier to set up. Assessing whether you can manage the installation independently or if professional assistance may be required ensures a smooth and hassle-free setup.
Price:
Setting a realistic budget for your impact screen is essential. Higher-quality screens with advanced features may come at a higher cost, so balancing your budget with the desired features ensures you acquire a screen that meets your expectations without overspending. Consider the long-term value and performance to make an informed decision based on your budget constraints.
Final thoughts
When shopping for a golf simulator impact screen, you must consider various factors, including material quality, durability, resolution, size, ease of installation, and price. The SIGPROTM Premium Golf Simulator Impact Screen is a great choice, and I would recommend it for its exceptional durability, minimal noise, and low bounce-back feature. Although it’s a bit expensive, it’s a worthwhile investment. If you are on a tight budget and seeking a less expensive alternative, choose the SIGTM Preferred Finished Golf Impact Screen.
